Beware the Penitent Gadarene
Last week’s column I managed to offend a fair swathe of my audience by using an acronym I didn’t make up in reference to the GOP’s vice-presidential candidate. Lesson learned: From now on, I’ll refer to women like Gov. Palin exclusively as “momshells.” In fact, I’m going to swear off using other people’s acronyms altogether. No more “MILFs,” “DWEMs” or “WASPs” will henceforth appear in my commentary. It smacks something of Sloth—like lifting morbid anecdotes from someone else’s ridiculous life. As if I needed to. Harrumph.
From now on, I’m only using acronyms I’ve coined myself. As our overlords print dollars by the wheelbarrow to pay for golden parachutes, we might as well mint our own hard currency. (I think I’ll call mine the Krupnik.) Faithful readers will remember the handy term BUCLs. It stands for “Brilliant Unemployable Catholic Losers,” and it describes certain graduates of Ivy League or Great Books colleges who contact me every six months or so in search of a vacant couch, achingly obvious advice they will ignore, make-work assignments they’ll turn in late, or bail. Before I moved to an undisclosed location, they’d sometimes just show up at my doorstep, with duffel bags full of overdue library books, a tale of woe, and a musty smell which even the beagles couldn’t stand. At last I started turning them away, explaining simply: “My dogs are allergic to you.” For an eerily realistic imitation of a BUCL, check out the poetry readings of my old acquaintance James McCoy. Who really did… graduate from a Great Books school. Ahem.
In the service of expanding our vocabulary of public discourse, I plan to roll out a new acronym from time to time—in much the way that the Franklin Mint periodically issues those fake coins that stoners watching late night TV believe will someday be “priceless.”
This week it’s the turn of the TOACANACs. No, this isn’t the name of a pre-Columbian tribe of Meso-American cannibals. Or maybe it is. But for my purposes this term denotes “Tramps Of A Certain Age Now Advocating Chastity.”
You’ve probably heard the choice barb aimed at the neocons: “It is splendid when the town whore gets religion and joins the church. Now and then she makes a good choir director, but when she begins to tell the minister what he ought to say in his Sunday sermons, matters have been carried too far.” This remark has been attributed variously to Stephen Tonsor, Phyllis Schlafly, and the Bl. Pope John XXIII. It’s clearly divinely inspired.
But TOACANACs (TWA-ka-NAKS) are a different story. A much more literal one. Viewed ethnographically, they’re a tribe of women (or “ex-gay” fundamentalists) who make a great point of informing hapless passersby exactly how widely they used to “throw it around.” They’ll lay it right out for you, in print or (far worse) in person: the depth, the breadth, the sheer geographical range over which they once put out. Perhaps they’re eager to emphasize the depth of the sins which Jesus forgave them, the more to magnify the saving mercies of… Whatever. Stop right there. If I might play the Prodigal Son’s annoying older brother for a moment, I’d like to share something with all the newly forty, neo-chaste folks out there: The rest of us don’t want to hear it. Don’t whine about how “unfulfilling” and “ultimately empty” you now consider all that really hot sex you were spreading across the lower 48—at least not to people who for reasons of high principle (e.g., fear of hellfire) have spent their dating lives taking cold showers, and hobbling home from dates with huevos agonistes. Go tell it to the pole-dancers and the gents who are stuffing their Spandex with twenties. They might not act on your message, but at least they deserve it.
I once knew a particularly ferocious TOACANAC I’ll call “ Clothilde.” She marked her fourth decade by at once putting on Jesus Christ and sixty pounds—conflating in at least my mind the Magdalene with the Gadarene. A failed operatic soprano, by the time I met her she was widely known as “Ilsa: She-Wolf of the Latin Mass.” Just the sight of Clothilde could turn a music director’s face greenish, like rancid veal. I’ve seen grown men spot her coming, drop their sheet music and simply run off down the street, without a word of explanation. As if we needed it.
At the parish I used to attend, Clothilde would flounce into practice late, tell the organist “Talk to the hand,” and sing at a volume that left all the other choristers sounding like chirping, glue-trapped mice. Convinced she was still irresistible, she’d deduce that any man who didn’t flirt with her was homosexual. And tell everyone in the parish. Since the only men who appreciated her charms in fact were catty queens themselves, that left them the only male parishioners she insisted weren’t gay. In the end, the choir director decided she had to go—and here he made his mistake. He tried to be tactful. “I’m following pre-Vatican II traditions,” he explained, proud of his cleverness. “So I’m organizing a boys’ choir.” No sooner had he gathered a group of hard-working kids from the neighborhood, and taught them the Missa de Angelis, than Clothilde had informed the entire parish the real reason why the choir director wanted a boys choir….
You guessed it: He was a “raging pedophile,” as she told anyone who’d listen—typically on the steps of the church as the choir finished the recessional. This was the middle 1990s, when such a charge was still a glimpse of stocking, and the rumor spread like ring worm in a sauna. Pretty soon, the scandal was serious enough that the pastor himself took notice. Too Roman to take on such a seedy subject in the pulpit, he made a point of attending (for the first time) our coffee hour—mixing imperiously in our midst and quietly murmuring. In the bad old days of clericalism, this would have been more than enough. But we, the laity, had been empowered by Vatican II. Clothilde went right back at him. “So Monsignor wants to protect a pedophile,” she’d say with a smile, sipping Earl Grey and shifting a Pantagruelian haunch. “I wonder why….”
Of course, Clothilde got what she wanted in the end. (Okay, that came out wrong; she certainly didn’t.) She drove off the choir director, at any rate. He tried to reason with people, talk down the nervous parents who wanted to pull their boys from the choir. He even attempted a confrontation with Clothilde. He was too shell-shocked to face her himself, but his wife marched up to the church one Sunday morning and grabbed Clothilde by her orchid corsage. And pleaded with her: “This man is my husband. We love each other. We have four children… do you know what this is doing to him?”
Clothilde stepped back, and gave the desperate wife a long, appraising look. Then she reared up to full height and said: “Oh please. I can tell from looking at you, this girl hasn’t ‘gotten it’ in years. Denial isn’t just a river in Egypt, Sweetie.” The woman stood there, stunned, as Clothilde thundered off, singing in a low voice Mozart’s “Exsultate Jubilate.”
EPILOGUE: The choir director found another job, in what I hope for his sake was an entirely different time zone. But Clothilde kept right on attending, singing loudly, perfectly in key—and always a half tempo faster or slower than the organist. She varied from week to week. This threw the members of every subsequent choir into confusion, which still prevailed at the parish when last I visited. But Clothilde adds to more than just the music. She also sets the moral tone. One week, a young priest of the most austere branch of the Franciscans attended the Latin Mass, and invited his brother. They were both straight-talking, guileless working class guys from the Bronx—a little rough around the edges. That has to explain why the brother thought it acceptable to bicycle down from Fordham Road and show up for Missa Cantata in a body-length, stretchy Speedo. It’s the kind of faux pas most Catholics overlook—or maybe we take the guy aside for a beer and explain to him there’s a dress code. But Clothilde had higher standards of reverence. She marched right up to the offending bicyclist, and right in front of his Capuchin brother announced: “I really didn’t appreciate having to spend the entire Mass looking at your penis.”
Beware, my son, the fierce TOACANAC. And for God’s sake, hide your candy.
Comments
“Momshell”
You may want to copyright that one.
Click to flag this comment as abusive
Will this tale be coming out in “graphic novel” format?
Will it be in the fiction or fantasy section?
Click to flag this comment as abusive
A working class guy in speedos? Color me sceptical.
Click to flag this comment as abusive
Anne Hutchinson was another. A Puritan version who was a fan of Cotton Mather but the same. The horrible harridan even has a statue.
http://www.mass.gov/?pageID=mg2terminal&L=6&L0=Home&L1=State+Government&L2=About+Massachusetts&L3=Interactive+State+House&L4=Inside+the+State+House&L5=Statues+in+Bronze&sid=massgov2&b=terminalcontent&f=interactive_statehouse_statue_hutchinson&csid=massgov2
Click to flag this comment as abusive
Ah, Krupnik! Wonderful little Polish restaurant around the corner, good pirozhki, good soups, wonderful Krupnik!
Click to flag this comment as abusive
“Id like to share something with all the ... “
So if you want to share something with her why not just send an email?
Click to flag this comment as abusive
In a way this is flat-out funny as hell (per usual) but the pathetic reality is it perfectly describes just how much masculinity has surrendered to feminism within the Body of Christ.
For crying out loud, Mr. Z., was there not ONE man with balls enough to tell the bitch to take a hike?
Click to flag this comment as abusive
Why invent a new acronym when for Clothilde, “Asshole” will do just fine? I know it might not be Christian but her various and sundry issues could have all been solved by a good hard shot to the nose followed by a kick in the ass down the front stairs.
The entire culture is prostrating themselves at the feet of bellowing Harpyia.
Click to flag this comment as abusive
Unfortunately Dirk the Catholic Church has lost that fighting spirit. Now we specialize in being the worlds doormat. Somehow we get a perverse delight in suffering abuse. Fitting since society at large is so readily dishing it out.
Click to flag this comment as abusive
Why bother with this tale - it’s a fictional account probably based, in small part, on some woman Zee encountered.
He enjoys spinning a good yarn.
Click to flag this comment as abusive
My Dear Mr. Zmirak,
For once I must ardently object to something you’ve written: was it really necessary to bless this creature with the name of Clovis’s most chaste and saintly wife, the very lady responsible for his baptism and the birth of Christian France? Surely she is deserving of greater reverence than this…
Click to flag this comment as abusive
Christine. That is humor. It is a name she least deserved although she would prolly think it apt
Click to flag this comment as abusive
“huevos agonistes”? You’re killing me!
Click to flag this comment as abusive
Spartacus,
I’m being a bit tongue-in-cheek myself, sir.
Click to flag this comment as abusive
Spartacus
There is a parish in my Deanery that let someone like this take over the parish. She chased out the Music Director and most of the Choir. She is the Liturgy Director and none cross her. She was only able to do this because the Pastor allowed it to happen. I don’t find the Liturgy that far off the usual horrible norm of these sad times but feel for my friends who left their ministry because of her.
Her parents on the other hand go to a parish where the pastor is in charge. He is a retired Air Force Chaplain and a Canon lawyer. He has enforced his own preferences and while I also felt for the folk mass people but the Pastor is the chief liturgist of the parish. I sit in with their choir at times if I happen to visit the parish. They have sound musicians.
My preference is for Gregorian chant but no one at all listens to me. Especially in my own parish.
Click to flag this comment as abusive
Paddy,
I’m trying not to respond to comments, but when somebody calls me a liar I feel the need. This all ACTUALLY HAPPENED. Sadly. I don’t make this stuff up. I don’t have to.
Click to flag this comment as abusive
Hilarious! But you forgot to give “Steve - San Francisco” credit for coining the term “Momshell” in the comment section of your last blog ‘Cosmetologist at a Hog Farm.’
Click to flag this comment as abusive
Exactly right, as Rayne.
Click to flag this comment as abusive
My preference is for Gregorian chant but no one at all listens to me. Especially in my own parish.
Durant. I read ya, brother. But, even in a liberal Diocese, surprises do happen.
I live in the liberal Diocese of Palm Beach, Florida and about an hour ago I got off the phone with a wonderful Priest who works at the Chancery.
I telephoned him in following-up a letter I had written to them months ago (Ive written several actually).
To make a LONG story shorter, in response to the Pope’s Summorum Pontificum, Bishop Barbarito sent two Priests out to Chi-Town to study with the Canons of St. John Cantius and now they are back Ministering in The Diocese (and forming Gregorian Scholas).
One is stationed at St. Martin de Porres in Jensen Beach, and one remains to be assigned.
I am finagaling behind the scenes to get the unassigned Priest assigned to my Parish and I offered to serve the EF Mass if it comes to my Parish.
IOW,Jesus makes all things new but he works through volunteers - us.
Longanimity is rewarding and it, sometimes, even bears fruit during our own lifetimes.
Fight the good fight. If the fight does not bear fruit during your lifetime, it will, in the lifetime of your children or your children’s children.
ALWAYS pray for the Pope, your Bishop, and your Pastor, NEVER sever Communion, and work like hell for what is right.
I tell you, my heart soared while I was speaking to this Priest and I am higher then I was back in the day when I was stoned and listening to Led Zeppelin
Click to flag this comment as abusive
Canons of St. John Cantius
They were wonderful in supporting the Sacred Music Colloquium.
Years ago I supported a Schola’s mass at a Monastery where the monks allowed an outside group to hold a chant mass once a month in the Chapel. Novus Ordo but at least in Latin with the Latin Ordinary and Propers. Flinging incense in the Summer was hot work in the non-Air Conditioned chapel but the acoustics were marvelous. I lost contact with them due to scheduling conflicts but I attended a mass last year and found it was stronger than ever though with new people. I keep a weather eye out for kindred souls and wait in hope.
AMDG
Click to flag this comment as abusive
This is an absolutely hilarious article, many thanks John Z.
But this convert is sad. I thought I’d left crap like this behind when I left the Anglican church. I’m afraid the convert’s bliss will like healing clay fall from my eyes and I’ll start to see such pride, vanity, and wrath in the characters in my own little Parish. I’d rather stay innocent as a dove and oblivious as an infant.
And as for the Franciscan Brother’s brother, why he didn’t just reply “custody of the eyes” and give a wink is beyond me.
Click to flag this comment as abusive
Post a Comment
By submitting this form, you give Taki's Magazine permission to publish this comment. Comments will be published at our discretion, and may be edited for clarity and length. Personal attacks, ethnic slurs, the riding of hobby horses and the beating of dead ones will be deleted as soon as they are detected by our small but alert staff. Repeat abusers of this policy will be barred from leaving comments. All comments reflect only the views of those posting them and not necessarily those of this website, its editors, or authors. For best formatting, please limit your response to one paragraph and don't hit "enter" to force line breaks.
Commenting is not available in this section entry.