Your Email:

Subject:

Message:
Entry: Who's Infallible Here, Anyway? The Human Life Review Chooses Party Over Church Link: http://www.takimag.com/site/article/wars_and_rumors_of_war#5446 Post contents: As a long time subscriber and reader of CHRONICLES and THE REMNANT, I applaud Scott Richert's article. He is dead right about James Hitchcock, whose career I have watched with interest since the 1960s. I have never considered him the "shining knight" that some do. I do agree most heartily with Sid Cundiff that not everything a pope simply says is of the Magisterium (parenthetical note here: as a worshipper at chapels of the Society of St. Pius X I would like to emphasize that! Archbishop Lefebvre, by the way, was excommunicated NOT for doctrinal reasons but for disciplinary one; there was never a question of his orthodoxy in doctrine); but the overwhelming weight of Catholic teaching (including Just War theolgy)militates against this war. It may not be of the same clarity as the Church's position on abortion, but it is just the same, very clear. Sent at: 2008 09 05