Your Email:

Subject:

Message:
Entry: Requiem for a Heavyweight Link: http://www.takimag.com/blogs/article/requiem_for_a_heavyweight1#707 Post contents: My comments are based exclusively on Jones' speech and the ideas he expresses therein. Some, not all, of his ideas seem flawed to me and I explained, to the best of my ability, why. I have no theory of a melting pot creating a "new single religion." Only simplistic models, created by the more arrogant type of sociology grad student, would presume such an absurdity. But from a historical standpoint, I do see a melting pot creating a common American white identity - transcending to some degree sectarian differences - in much the same way that some other nation-states, like France, Germany, England(and to a lesser extent, Britain), have forged a common national identity from seperate tribes and regions. I appreciate that Jones does not agree against Jews from a genetic basis, and as I stated before, he presents an interesting argument and analysis in many respects. I would not dismiss him the way Peter Brimelow did at VDARE a week or so ago. The Muslim religion, more than any other except perhaps Judaism, does seem to trump racial identity, as you point out. All the more reason to ban completely ANY Muslim immigration into the United States, and to remove those already here who are not already citizens. Sent at: 2008 07 23