Your Email:

Subject:

Message:
Entry: All Soul's Day Link: http://www.takimag.com/site/article/all_souls_day#8372 Post contents: Sid, please, please, get your theology right...Fr. Feeney interpreted "extra ecclesiam, nullus salus" in an univocal manner, not recognizing the three media of belonging to the church (simple baptism, baptism via martyrdom, and baptism of desire, either implicitly or explicitly). His view has nothing to do with what I wrote. Neither does coercion (as I have stated here, and elsewhere til my face turns blue!). I've read Harrison's book, and Michael Davies (as well as several other theologians) has much the better of him. I will repeat what Ives Congar said...there is a real and formal difference in what Dignitatis humanae says, and what previous popes, and in particular, the Blessed Pius IX, have taught. My last word on this topic. It is useless to debate with you on this.... Sent at: 2008 11 20