Marcus Epstein

Can Barack Obama and Racist Pseudo Science Coexist?

Posted by Marcus Epstein on May 17, 2008

Justin’s latest ventures in behavioral genetics and differential psychology gives us a stunningly logical argument: Barack Obama is so smart that there is no way that blacks could, on average, have lower IQs than whites, or at the very least, not as low as the various racist pseudo-scientists who he doesn’t bother to name (or read?)

I’ll be the first to admit-- or should I say the 250 millionth to admit--that Barack Obama is intelligent and articulate. I’m sure Obama is smarter than George W Bush and probably even John McCain; but he’s not a genius. I wouldn’t be surprised if Mitt Romney, Bill Clinton, and Hillary Clinton are smarter than him, but we don’t hear much about how smart they are.  That everyone has to go out of their way to mention how intelligent and articulate he is, suggests that they implicitly acknowledge that he is an anomaly among African Americans.

As I said earlier, I am not saying that racial differences in intelligence are genetic and that while Obama is smart, he’s not a genius. But for the sake of argument let’s assume Barack Obama has a genius IQ of 145 and that the racist pseudoscience is actually correct. Are these two incompatible?

The best known pseudoscientific book that argues that intelligence testing does matter and may have some genetic and racial component is Charles Murray and Richard Herrnstein’s The Bell Curve. The title refers to the Bell shaped normal distribution of IQ scores. According to pseudo-scientists, different racial groups have different, but overlapping distributions.

Justin has already expressed his aversion to statistics, and perhaps he thinks the whole concept of a standard deviation is racist pseudoscience since it was discovered by Francis Galton, but I hope you all will humor me.

A standard deviation is a unit of statistical measure that is a unit of the probability of an outcome would occur. The more standard deviations from the mean, the less likely it will occur. This chart shows the likelihood of up to three standard deviations on a bell curve.

In IQ, each standard deviation is 15 points. So every 15 points away from the mean, a random person has the above likelihood of having that IQ .

Racist pseudoscientist Richard Lynn estimates that the average IQ of Kenyans is approximately 72. This is quite low. It’s considered borderline retarded, and nearly two standard deviations lower than those welfare taking, illegitimate child having, Hillary Clinton voting rapists in West Virginia. Nonetheless, this means that 13.6% of the population has an IQ between 87 and 102, 2.1% of the population has an IQ between 102 and 117, .3% of the population as an IQ between 117 and 132, and .006% has an IQ above 132.

As Justin acknowledged, Obama’s mother was White. The originators of racist pseudoscience normed IQ tests at 100 for the average White score. So according to the pseudoscientists, the average IQ of a half-White, half-Kenyan would be 86. The genius IQ of 145, is slightly four standard deviations above 86.

That means that approximately one in 16,000 Cau-Kenyans would have an IQ of 145 or higher. This is less likely than the one in 300 whites who would have such a score, but not impossibility.

In reality, Obama is much more likely to have that score. Racist pseuedo-scientists admit that their pseudoscience is not a perfect science. They fully acknowledge that the gap between whites and Africans is not entirely genetic. While they don’t think that forced busing and head start would create black Einstein’s, they believe that basic nutrition and education have an impact. This means that a random Kenyan baby in the raised in the right environment would have an IQ above the average of 72. Obama was certainly raised in such an environment.

Furthermore, regardless of what the average Kenyan IQ is, Barack Obama Sr. was certainly on the far right end of its Bell Curve, and his mother was smarter than the average white person.  Hypothetically let’s say that Obama Sr.was in the top 1% of Kenyans, and Obama’s mother was in the top 10% of whites, then there is a 1 in 50 percent chance that Obama would have a genius IQ.

Given that Obama is seen as the greatest hope for America, I think that’s pretty good odds. 

Comments

So you are saying that 100% more likely to be smart than blacks and it’s not racist?  I t

Even if you don’t agree with these racists, you are reading too much.

Posted by Marie on May 17, 2008.

Click to flag this comment as abusive

Barack got into Columbia, which like several Ivy League schools, would compete hard to get a black in the top percentiles of conceptual ability. Estimating 130 might be more accurate. Again one sees the great utility of knowing the group means; as it allows one to predict the threshold value where applicants from a group can be expected to cluster in very high degree. If blacks without some special sport or highly- recruitable specialized talent have a cut-off of IQ 125 for Columbia, almost all of them will be within 125-130, due to the group means of their larger population that they come from. Psychology is not a science and doesn’t even pretend to be, neither is economics which makes extravagant assumptions about laws governing human behavior and on statistical grounds. There is not known to be any immorality in using group means to predict individual results, when it’s done reasonably. Right-wing outlets should have no problem with the Inequality of Man; it’s a problem for the left, and a resource for exploitation by the power-greedy of all descriptions.

The Obama phenomena is as such:

Mulatto (higher IQ) that identifies as black.

Affirmative action culture that puts ‘articulate’ blacks on top of society.

Hidden disdain for traditional American values.

Its no wonder the MSM drool all over this guy.

Posted by Phil on May 17, 2008.

Click to flag this comment as abusive

To me, it seems unlikely that Hillary is smarter than Senator Obama.  The blunders she makes seems to preclude any great intelligence on her part.  From my experience, megalomaniacs that yell and scream and treat people like dirt can actually get pretty far in life.  That and a lot of stupid voters in New York got her to the presidential race.

Posted by David on May 18, 2008.

Click to flag this comment as abusive

I was rather intrigued by the pseudoarticle of Marcus Epstein. I believe he is conflating his irrational dislike and antipathy for blacks with the genuine pseudoscience of racism.

Two on the subject.

The Intelligence of Blacks
http://www.fredoneverything.net/FOE_Frame_Column.htm

Race, Rushton, And Us
http://www.fredoneverything.net/FOE_Frame_Column.htm

Wrong links above.

The Intelligence of Blacks
http://www.fredoneverything.net/BlackIQ.shtml

Race, Rushton, And Us
http://www.fredoneverything.net/Rushton.shtml

Hillary clinton managed to get into Yale Law School without affirmative action whatever stupid decisions she may have made, she’s pretty smart. (the great difference between “Wisdom” and “intelligence")

It’s interesting that every single post on the subject has gotten 100 responses besides this one.  My guess is because it is too to the point, so the race deniers can’t even pretend to come up with any response to his facts.

Posted by pat on May 18, 2008.

Click to flag this comment as abusive

I doubt Obama has an IQ much above 135 or so (still smarter than Bush, and much much smarter than JFK), but yes, you’re right of course.  BTW Lynn suggests African-Americans with no white admixture median IQ probably 80, 80+100/2 = median 90 for a half white half black American child.  Since Obama’s parents were both PhD grade students, albeit not in the toughest subjects, you can probably add around 30 points to that, for an expected median IQ ca 120.  If he’s IQ 135 that’s only about 1 SD over the median expected IQ.

Kudos to Mr. Epstein for thoroughly (and amusingly) dismantling Raimondo’s huffy illogic.

Yes, Raimondo is embarrassing himself and should read up on race and intelligence before commenting. Give me Rothbard over Raimondo any day.

Race is real. “Racism” is a social construct.

My guess is that Mitt Romney is one of the dumbest people to ever run for public office.  He routinely looked the fool in all the debates.  He completely failed to differentiate himself materially from McCain and was easily bullied by McCain.  He had a liberal record in Massachusets and tried to change himself to a conservative overnight by borrowing from Ron Paul.  He represents everything that is wrong with this country and ran for office when corporate elites such as himself have just about bled this country dry.  He spent more of his own money on his campaign than any other candidate and only managed a distant second to McCain.

Post a Comment

By submitting this form, you give Taki's Magazine permission to publish this comment. Comments will be published at our discretion, and may be edited for clarity and length. Personal attacks, ethnic slurs, the riding of hobby horses and the beating of dead ones will be deleted as soon as they are detected by our small but alert staff. Repeat abusers of this policy will be barred from leaving comments. All comments reflect only the views of those posting them and not necessarily those of this website, its editors, or authors. For best formatting, please limit your response to one paragraph and don't hit "enter" to force line breaks.

Commenting is not available in this section entry.