Dispassionate Conservatism
Wilhelm Ropke’s name is often misused by lovers of Leviathan. I once heard that Karl Rove, of all people, was reading A Humane Economy, and found in it an inspiration for the mindless slogan “compassionate conservatism.” Clearly Rove was no better at reading economics than at reading the public mind. If there’s one president in the past 30 years whose policies would have horrified this good German liberal, it’s George W. Bush--whose reign of error combined mind-boggling profligacy with public funds, a careless eagerness to send other men’s sons (and DAUGHTERS!) into battle, and contempt for reason and even the English language.
Since lately I’ve been writing and speaking about Ropke, I’ve been hearing back from people who wonder what he might have said about current problems--for instance, the mortgage lending crisis. When a colleague wrote me about this question, I wrote the following--my best attempt to apply this wise man’s principles to today’s economic crisis:
Wilhelm Ropke knew the importance of encouraging widespread home-ownership. Indeed, as a market economist influenced by the Distributists (Chesterton and Belloc), he thought most people should also have enough land to farm--as a back-up in case of economic depression. However, he also held the virtue of THRIFT as essential to the survival of a free economy and healthy social order. He would not have acceded to our current system of government-backed loans to buyers of homes with dubious credit, and would heartily disapproved of the practice which gave rise to the current crisis--banks encouraging people to “trade up” to homes they really cannot
afford. I suspect that he would see the situation today as an opportunity for the government to step back, banks to feel the discipline of the market, and individuals to take a more realistic view of the size and quality of homes they
can afford--and the wisdom of seeing them primarily as investment properties, or cash cows they can mortgage to fund consumer spending.
It turns out I’m not the only person wondering “What Would Wilhelm Do?” There’s an excellent piece on Lewrockwell.com which goes into the subject in greater depth. Check it out here.
Comments
John, I was hoping to be able to meet you there in Indianapolis, but other events intervened. Please make the papers available for those of us who cannot be there.
Click to flag this comment as abusive
Roves favorite book was Myron Magnets book ‘The Dream and the Nightmare’ and I would think this is where his idea of compassionate conservatism was ripped off from.
http://www.manhattan-institute.org/html/_wsj-what_is_compassionate_con.htm
Compassionate conservatism derails the Democratic Party’s greatest rhetorical advantage, its demonstrably empty claim of a monopoly on caring about the worst-off. -Myron Magnet
Click to flag this comment as abusive
Dr. Zmirak,
Well said!
I have gained many insghts from reading Ropke and your own writings about Ropke.
Click to flag this comment as abusive
Alas. In today’s economy, Ropke would find that when people
practice thrift it is called “lack of consumer confidence” and it
is bad economic omen…
Our economy is the closest thing to a perpetual motion machine. If people
stopped buying what they cannot afford and saved instead, it would be a catastrophe of
unbelievable proportios.
Until we can come up with an idea of how to stop this juggernaut, then arguments about
public vs. private,and government vs. free market will only be tinkering at the edges.
Click to flag this comment as abusive
Post a Comment
By submitting this form, you give Taki's Magazine permission to publish this comment. Comments will be published at our discretion, and may be edited for clarity and length. Personal attacks, ethnic slurs, the riding of hobby horses and the beating of dead ones will be deleted as soon as they are detected by our small but alert staff. Repeat abusers of this policy will be barred from leaving comments. All comments reflect only the views of those posting them and not necessarily those of this website, its editors, or authors. For best formatting, please limit your response to one paragraph and don't hit "enter" to force line breaks.
Commenting is not available in this section entry.